Looking at both sides of the debate
Socrates once said, “There is only one good, knowledge, and one evil, ignorance“. We would therefore remiss if our blog or site did not include something anti-raw sites purposely exclude: an honest, open discussion of what is being promoted, with a look at both sides of the raw and real food for pets debate.
Why feed raw? Fur kids have been fed McKibble and McCan for the past fifty or so years with what seems to be great results. Cats and dogs are not dying outright from starvation or malnutrition, and seem to be happy and fairly healthy. You certainly can get dogs with glossy coats and healthy bodies that live well into their teens while being fed McKibble and McCan. Yet the veterinary community has been seeing increases in things like cancer, obesity, diabetes, unilateral hip dysplasia, dermatitises, food allergies, kidney problems, pancreas problems, and liver problems (and their medical techniques and methods have evolved tremendously to deal with these; many veterinarians are very capable people who mean well and can be quite good at treating illness and disease). Just about every system in the dog has been affected in some way, shape, or form by some disease or problem that did not “exist” prior to the advent of McKibble and McCan or was not recognized as a big issue in a similar manner as us pet parents are starting to awaking to nutrition ourselves. Part of this increase is due to the fact that more people own pets today and that illnesses are more quickly diagnosed nowadays, but many of these diseases have been shown to have strong links to diet – particularly in human research (like adult onset diabetes and obesity and cancer, for example). Many of our pets’ body processes parallel our own, so who is to say that processed food will not affect them similarly?
But on the whole, most people are happy to feed their dogs McKibble and McCan and coexist with smelly dog turds and stinky dog breath. Dogs are dogs; they are supposed to smell, right? Within the past 10-15 years or so it has finally been recognized that stinky breath is a problem for dogs because it underlies a bigger problem: periodontal disease. (download: Veterinary Periodontal Disease (PDF). The pet industry has played off of this tremendously, bringing about an era of pet chews, dental bones, toothbrushes, toothpastes, plaque-scraping foods and chewies and toys, etc. More things to spend your money on because your fur kids needs them to be healthy, right? The problem of big smelly dog turds has everyone up in arms, as these turds pollute our parks, side-walks, streets, and communities. It is the responsible owners or pet parents who have to suffer, as the turd problem has resulted in stricter leash laws, dog ownership laws, and in some communities an outright “dogs are not welcome” attitude, plus a plethora of “quick fixes” to help manage the problem: pooper scoopers, waste digesters, special scooping baggies to carry with you on walks, extra enzymes to add to the dog’s food so it will digest more of it. Has anyone ever questioned why they do not treat these problems at their source instead of just dealing with the symptoms as they surface?
Yes, pet parents, guardians and slaves have questioned this as well as the whole idea of pet feed; hence, raw fooding, or natural diets, has been “resurfacing“, so to speak. Many people call it a “fad” without realizing that raw fooding has been around a heck of a lot longer than McKibble and McCan: one million years of raw to only 100 years – at the most – of McKibble and McCan. Pelleted, processed feed is the fad that has somehow managed to integrate itself into every single aspect of our pets’ lives: medical care, training, leisure, nutrition, showing, breeding, you name it. This is, by and large, the way people feed their pets. It is easy, convenient, relatively cheap, and provides a much-needed outlet for all the waste products we as a society create (yep, waste products). Some entrepreneurial person – James Spratt – got the idea of feeding “biscuits” to our dogs as a meal, and the very first dog kibble was born. Read our post titled “Through the Looking Glass” about how the industry came about. These biscuits then evolved into foods that contained all the meats and by-products that were no longer fit for human consumption;- particularly after the 1906 Pure Food and Drug Act and the 1906 Meat Inspection Act was passed in the United States, which created the “meat dichotomy” of “fit for human consumption” and “unfit for human consumption“. Something had to be done with all that “unfit” meat… And thus, modern commercial foods were created. McKibble and McCan is simply a by-product of our industrial era that ushered in modernity and the desire to do things cheap, easy, and fast. It is no wonder that many of the big-name brands of dog food are made by companies that create a lot of other food products – Nestle, Mars, Colgate-Palmolive, etc. They have easy access to cheap ingredients made by their own factories.
But McKibble and McCan have come a long way since their early prototypes. They have improved much, and there are a number of smaller companies that produce holistic, organic, or premium McKibble and McCan from human grade ingredients that are of great quality as far as commercial foods go. The majority of pet parents and guardians are happy to just feed brand-name, pre-made McKibble and McCan to their pets because it is convenient, easy, and their animals eat the food and appear to do well on it. They are part of the consumer society that swallows slick advertisements hook, line, and sinker. And if there is one thing pet food companies have down, it is advertising. They advertise all over the place: on TV, on the web, in hundreds of magazines, in schools, at dog shows (think of the Eukanuba Tournament of Champions; free bags of the sponsor’s kibble are given to the winners at many dog shows.), at zoos, on billboards, and (most importantly) in your veterinarian’s office (think of all those shelves filled with Purina foods, Hill’s Science Diet, etc.). Raw fooding, however, has no such advertising capabilities, because people are supporting their local butchers, ranchers, farmers, independent resellers such as ourselves, etc., and are encouraging sustainable living practices rather than paying big bucks to make people buy some commercially-produced biscuit-based McKibble and McCan product. Raw feeding’s advertising is through word-of-mouth and through the healthy dogs and cats that are fed such a diet.
One can rightfully ask: why raw and not McKibble and McCan? Concerned pet parents and guardians are asking this every day, and some are coming to the realization that while their cats and dogs may be doing well, or surviving, they could be doing better and thrive! This is one of the reasons pet parents, guardians and slaves switch their pets if their pets do not have some major health problem. They switch because they believe their dogs or cats can have better quality lives if they are fed a raw diet. Sure, the dog’s coat may be shiny and it may have a fit body while eating McKibble and McCan, but they believe raw feeding can make it better and healthier.
A kibble-fed dog, while exhibiting a soft, shiny coat and a seemingly healthy body will often still exhibit the following:
- Dog breath (rancidity and stinkiness may vary);
- Stained teeth, tartar covered teeth, or teeth encrusted with calculus;
- Periodontal disease (85% of kibble-fed dogs over the age of 3 have this)
- Itchy skin Doggy odour to coat (varies in intensity);
- Body is too flaccid and may feel soft or ‘doughy’ to the touch, despite dog maintaining the proper weight;
- Large poops relative to body size that do not decompose quickly (softness and stinkiness may vary);
- Small fatty benign tumours that thrive from the constant supply of sugars provided by all the carbohydrates in the diet 1 [Google Books]
- Greasy feel to the coat (greasiness may vary), resulting in frequent (once a month or more) bathing;
- Premature ageing caused by periodontal disease and immune system ‘overload’ (immune system is constantly working against the toxins pouring into the body from the mouth and is in a constant state of arousal, Dr Lonsdale book)
Most people consider all the above-mentioned problems normal;- how did we get to the point where we consider all this normal? Since most people have never encountered raw fed dogs, they do not know what they are looking for and do not have anything to which they can compare their dogs. They may think their dog’s breath and health is fine until they smell a raw-fed dog’s breath and “see” its health, just like many people think their dog is “well-trained” (it “sits” and “comes” when they ask … sometimes) until they come across a truly impeccably trained animal.
Raw fooding pet parents, guardians and slaves have woken up to the fact that their pets could have a better quality of life if they were fed a species appropriate raw diet that nature designed for them. They realized that there is a big difference between eating enough to survive and eating well and thrive. McKibble and McCan provided their pets with sufficient caloric intake and seemed to meet all their pets’ nutritional requirements, but were their animals really living well and healthfully? They said ‘no’, and turned to a more natural way of fooding their animals.
So what about all these arguments against raw fooding put forward by other pet owners, veterinarians, and pet food companies? Is there any validity to them? Since this is an honest and candid look at raw fooding, we will be frank: yes, these claims may have some validity to them, but the “problems” with raw fooding are not the problems of epidemic, drastic proportions that they are made out to be. There are risks to fooding raw, just as there are risks to feeding McKibble and McCan. No one seems to mention the risks of feeding McKibble and McCan, perhaps because pet food companies have been very good at making people believe McKibble and McCan is a risk-free diet for their pets.
Facts do not cease to exist because they are ignored~Aldous Huxley
Here are some of the risks of feeding raw:
Yes, choking can happen with raw meaty bones. The primary culprit is a raw meaty bone that is too small for the dog, such as single chicken wings or necks. To prevent this from occurring, feed big raw meaty bones to your bigger fur kids. Additionally, dogs that have been eating McKibble and McCan must learn how to chew. They do not chew their kibble but typically “inhale” and gulp the food down; they try to do this with their first raw meaty bone and quickly learn that they need to CHEW their food. So choking can and does occasionally happen. However, think of all the other things that dogs choke on: kibble, pieces of rawhide, rocks, sticks, water, raquet balls, tennis balls, broken-off pieces of synthetic chew bones, pieces of toys. People tell you your dog will choke to death on raw bones, but they conveniently neglect to mention all the other things dogs choke on, including kibble (ever hear your pet scarf its food and then suddenly give a nice big ‘HORK’? Your pet just choked. Good thing they managed to cough it up; other dogs have not been so lucky.). Heck, dogs will choke on their own spit!! The truth of it is that any object the dog places into its mouth presents a choking hazard. More dogs choking on and then dying from tennis balls than what we have heard of raw-fed animals choking on their raw meaty bones (let alone dying from them!).
Intestinal Perforation and Obstruction
Yes, these could happen and have happened to dogs. However, as one JAVMA article put it: “the actual incidence of complications resulting from the ingestion of raw bones is unknown” 2. People are claiming that this happens all the time without ever providing evidence for these claims. Here are some other things that will cause perforated intestines and obstructions (and always keep in mind that dogs swallow some pretty weird things, including things like knives, pieces of glass, needles and thread):
- Cooked bones. These can and do splinter, anywhere from mouth to anus. NEVER feed them to your pets. Most claims of intestinal perforations caused by bones results from cooked bones, not raw. How can you tell the difference? The cooked bone remains hard and unchanged, albeit stained by the stomach acids. Raw bones generally are broken down chemically in the stomach and are soft and squishy (so it does not seem like they can do much perforating, then);
- Chewed up tennis balls (obstruction);
- Sticks (obstruction and perforation);
- String (obstruction, entanglement);
- Rawhide (obstruction);
- Rocks (obstruction and perforation; this is a rather common one, as eating rocks can be a sign of rabies vaccinosis);
- Broken off, swallowed chunks of toys or synthetic bones (obstruction, possibly perforation).
This happens if the dog is fed too much bone. There is a simple solution: stop feeding so much bone, and feed more meat, organs or complete minced meal packs. If the dog has too hard of a time passing faeces, increase the meat and decrease the bone. Remember that dogs get constipated by kibble as well, so this is not an exclusive “raw feeding” problem.
Yes, this could possibly happen, but it is rather rare (even in kibble-fed dogs) and usually occurs only in unwell animals that are incapable of dealing with a population of bacteria (which, coincidentally, is all throughout their intestines anyway): immune compromised pets, sick pets, animals that have an underlying health issue. As with all other anti-raw claims, you cannot take this one at face value. You need to probe and question. What, exactly, was the animal being fed? Were there any other complicating factors? Was the bacteria septicaemia secondary to some other health problem or following recent vaccination (which can depress the immune system by 80% for as long as 10 days post-vaccination)? Can they conclusively determine that the dog got “sick” from its food (remember, bacteria are absolutely everywhere, and dogs often have a habit of eating anything and everything)? The unfortunate truth of it is that many vets and pet owners will simply blame the diet than work to find the real cause. An example of this is on the Rawfed.com homepage: the article of the two cats that supposedly died from salmonella, article titled “Two Cats Died of Salmonella from Raw Meat“. If you want a more in-depth discussion of bacteria, see our post titled “Are Raw Diets Safe?“. Additionally, if a raw-fed dog (or any dog) is afflicted with bacterial septicaemia, one must ask “Why? Why this dog? Why now?” Not EVERY dog (raw-fed or otherwise) is afflicted with bacterial septicemia, so there must be something going on that made this dog susceptible to an overgrowth of bacteria.
Pancreatitis, kidney disease, and other diseases claimed to be linked to raw feeding are in the same boat as bacterial septicaemia. What generally happens is that a) there are underlying factors, b) there is an underlying disease, and c) the raw diet brings these to light. With pancreatitis, it is typically kibble-fed dogs that suffer from it when they receive a fatty meat they do not usually get. It is also incredibly important to note that fat does not cause pancreatitis; excess fat is simply a trigger for pancreatitis and may start the cascade of effects in the pancreas. If ingesting a fatty meal triggers a bout of pancreatitis, then that is indicative of some other underlying problem with the pancreas (again, ask “Why this dog? Why now?” Not every dog that eats raw meat or high quantities of fat “gets” pancreatitis, so something about that particular dog indicates “susceptibility“); the pancreatitis itself is a symptom that the pancreas (and possibly other organs) are not well, because a healthy dog with a healthy pancreas will not suffer from pancreatitis. Surprisingly, many dogs that previously suffered from these diseases while eating McKibble and McCan have dramatically improved since switching to a raw real food diet. Just wander around the Facebook (and other social media platforms) raw feeding group and you will hear some amazing testimonials. Just the fact that kibble-fed dogs can also suffer horrific and deadly bouts of pancreatitis should be sufficient to show that this is not a “raw feeding” problem, particularly when dogs with pancreas problems can be greatly helped from a raw diet (since it is easier to digest and actually places less demand on the pancreas). Can pancreatitis or kidney disease happen in a raw-fed dog? Yes, they could. All things are possible, particularly when one has no control over the kind of start the dog received in life (breeding, what the parents were fed, what the pup was fed, what vaccinations and dewormers it received, etc.).
Yes, this can happen, but if you are getting your meat from a human-approved source, this is not an issue (despite people trying to blow it out of proportion and make you think it is). Just think about the kind of meat that goes into kibble (dead, dying, diseased, or disabled – no? Read our post titled “From Trash to Cash” ..) and you will be much happier knowing your dog is getting real human-grade meat in its fresh form. Yes, there will always be a minimal risk that your dog can contract some parasite from meat, but most parasites are not life-threatening and can be dealt with easily (did we mention there was a minimal risk?). Contrast this to the toxic molds that caused thousands of bags of dog food to be pulled off the shelves once dogs starting getting sick and dying.
It comes down to this …
Everything in life has a risk associated with it. That is the way life is. Regardless of what you feed or food your pets, there will always be some sort of risk. These are the main risks of fooding a raw diet, but they are minimal risks, and people who feed raw truly feel that the benefits outweigh any possible risks. Claims of “hundreds of dogs” suffering from punctured intestines or “a high percentage of dogs” dying from pancreatitis induced by the “high fat content” in meat are unfounded scare tactics and undocumented generalizations. Kibble has risks, as well. Even feeding your dog a premium McKibble and McCan still puts it at risk for choking, bloat, cancer, diabetes, obesity, telescoping bowel, anal sac problems, joint problems, and periodontal disease (which allows bacteria and bacterial toxins to enter your pet’s body and affect every single organ). Home-cooked diets also have their own set of risks: unbalanced nutrition (since irresponsible cooking can alter and destroy many of the necessary nutrients) resulting in a myriad of health problems (some of which are fatal or irreversible), small intestine bacterial overgrowth, and periodontal disease, for example. Everything has risks whether we acknowledge them or not.
No one is going to force you to make a decision. This is your choice and no one else’s. Choosing to food raw will put you in conflict with the majority of vets and pet owners, and you will undoubtedly be attacked for your choice by both ignorant (yet well-meaning) people and by educated people. Be informed, be educated, and be prepared. The fact that you came to us already speaks volumes about you: you have an open mind and are willing to read and think critically, something most vehement anti-raw people do not share with you. Personally, we cannot help but wonder why raw fooding provokes such deep inward feelings and reactions from people and why we have come to believe that dogs are supposed to eat pre-formed pellets and nothing else. “Dogs do not need variety“. “Do not feed your dog people food or it will become finicky and will not eat its dog food“. We have to wonder why!! Real food versus processed pellets sprayed with fat? No wonder dogs prefer “people food“.
In the End, it is ALL about Food …
We’re told that we (huumans, us) need to eat whole, minimally processed fresh foods, and that we should vary our diets. We often get different advise for our pets. It is this basic chasm we are trying to close at Raw Food for Pets.
Don’t eat anything your great-great grandmother wouldn’t recognize as food. There are a great many food-like items in the supermarket your ancestors wouldn’t recognize as food… stay away from these~ Michael Pollan
If you read Dr. Beckers’ blog, books & websites, then you will also agree with us, the truth is, food is just food. There’s no “dog food“, “people food“, “cat good“, “bird food” – it’s all just food, with the balance and ingredients differing depending on the species. A fresh raw and real food diet is best for all living beings. We therefore believe that a fresh, species-appropriate raw diet provides support for the body to maintain a vibrant state of being for many years.
Our advice: feed a fresh raw food diet to your fur kids. It’s the most important component to promote a long and healthy life for your animals. You might see such radical changes that you’ll be inspired to overhaul your own diet! We ended up doing just that!
However, we also realize that many of our pet parents and guardians need convenience in your busy lives. We want fast food and our food fast – for our animals and for ourselves. The easy answer is McKibble and McCan, the answer most of us accepted with little thought about the effect of dry food on general health of our fur kids. Food has not been considered very important for human health for a long time, let alone for our pets. However, we are beginning to understand that there is no substitute for eating real food ourselves. The same is true for our fur kids. Many of the chronic and acute diseases suffered by humans and animals are directly related to diet.
If your fur kids are already bursting with health, you may not see a big difference when you switch to fresh food. If your fur kid has chronic health problems, you are likely to see those improvements. You may notice that some of the small problems you thought were “just age” have diminished, even disappeared.
We think you’ll see and feel a big change. As you leave our site, we hope that you will give some serious thought to the material presented here. Remember that really learning something makes one uncomfortable because one realizes they are deficient in some way; no one enjoys coming to that realization, especially when they must present or project a particular, well-learned image to others. We encourage you to work through the discomfort and to not just dismiss everything you have read here simply because it does not fall in line with what you personally believe or practice. Be critical in your thought and analysis of EVERYTHING, not just the myth arguments. When you see pet food advertisements, question the reality they are presenting to you. What things are being left out and unspoken? Everything that is presented to you via the media has been altered in some way to represent a new reality – the reality certain parties want you, the consumer, to hear – so what other realities are being neglected and ignored?
References and Research
- 1.Damjanov I. Pathology for the Health Professions . 4th ed. Saunders; 2011. https://www.amazon.com/Pathology-Health-Professions-4e-Related/dp/1437716768.
- 2.Schlesinger D, Joffe D. Raw food diets in companion animals: a critical review. Can Vet J. 2011;52(1):50-54. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21461207.